TJ THELEN'S COLLECTION
The Thelen Reserve
Behind the Bottles / American whiskey

Rare
Character

Last updated Last researched

A curator’s eye. A barrel’s own voice.

AMERICAN WHISKEY / A curator’s eye. A barrel’s own voice.

Rare Character approaches American whiskey through selection rather than a single house recipe. Its world includes individual barrels, composed blends and revived names older than the company. The connecting thread is the search for distinctive whiskey and a fitting audience. Understanding the producer means following those choices.[24]

Symbolic single-cask selection, amber tasting glasses and customized label art
Founded
2021[1]
Identity
Independent American whiskey selector and bottler[2]
Founders
Pablo Moix and Peter Nevenglosky[1]
Kentucky role
Further maturation and bottling, with release-specific origins[11]
01 / Origins & people

A hospitality palate. A wider whiskey canvas.

A bar’s perspective, a bottler’s freedom

The hospitality disruption of 2020 sparked the Rare Character idea. Pablo Moix and Peter Nevenglosky founded the company the following year. Their complementary experience joined whiskey selection with spirits brand development. The modern business is separate from its revived labels’ much older histories.[1]

A menu rather than one house recipe

The flagship offers a rotating selection of bourbon, rye and finished whiskey, drawing on independent Scotch bottling. A customer’s preferred aroma, texture or intensity guides the selection. Diversity belongs to the format: the next barrel need not taste identical.[2]

Historical names, modern decisions

Fortuna’s revival gives this approach another dimension. The team studied vintage bottlings and corresponded with the Hollenbach family to develop a target for the modern whiskey. That is a reconstruction informed by evidence and tasting. It does not turn the new company into an uninterrupted nineteenth-century distillery, nor prove the modern bourbon came from the original production site.[3]

Symbolic hands arranging a whiskey tasting

Pablo Moix

Co-founder and whiskey selector

Moix’s hospitality background supplies the tasting perspective. Long before Rare Character, he selected barrels for Los Angeles bars and restaurants. In the company’s present work, he evaluates barrels and looks for the character that deserves its own bottling or a place in a blend. His role is most clearly understood through selection and composition.[10]

Peter Nevenglosky

Co-founder and spirits entrepreneur

Nevenglosky brought spirits-brand experience through Drifter Spirits, including Avuá Cachaça and Svöl Aquavit. Rare Character gave that experience an American whiskey focus. These career connections do not make those other spirits Rare Character whiskey brands.[1]

02 / The illustrated history

Earlier names. A modern beginning.

The first three entries follow historic labels before Rare Character existed. The modern company begins in 2021, with each later revival and release retaining its own identity.

Symbolic illustration: Fortuna’s earlier life
1880s

Fortuna’s earlier life

In Rare Character’s account, Phillip Hollenbach established Fortuna during the late nineteenth century. The label survived into the 1960s before disappearing. This is the heritage of a revived brand, well before Rare Character’s own founding.[4]

Symbolic illustration: The original Brook Hill
Around 1900

The original Brook Hill

The 2024 revival announcement traces Brook Hill to Joseph L. Friedman and John W. Keiler around the turn of the twentieth century. Rare Character would later use the historic identity for a new selection of bourbon and rye.[5]

Symbolic illustration: Black Maple Hill begins
2000

Black Maple Hill begins

The producer’s relaunch history dates Black Maple Hill’s introduction by Paul Joseph of CVI Brands to 2000. It was a sourced label, with later Kentucky and Oregon chapters. Its history precedes Rare Character’s involvement.[21]

Symbolic illustration: An idea during a shutdown
2020

An idea during a shutdown

The founders identify the hospitality shutdown as the moment the idea took shape, drawing on relationships developed around bars, restaurants and spirits.[1]

Symbolic illustration: Rare Character takes shape
2021

Rare Character takes shape

Moix and Nevenglosky founded Rare Character around American whiskey selection and individualized presentation. This is the company’s foundation, not a distillery opening.[1]

Symbolic illustration: Fortuna returns
September 20, 2022

Fortuna returns

Rare Character announced Fortuna’s return with Andy Shapira participating in the revival. The original modern expression was a minimum six-year Kentucky straight bourbon bottled at 102 proof, assembled in six-barrel batches. Those specifications describe that introduction.[3]

Symbolic illustration: Brook Hill is revived
March 14, 2024

Brook Hill is revived

The Brook Hill announcement introduced a new home for especially prized selections. Initial offerings included a ten-year bourbon and eleven-year rye, bottled at cask strength. The project revived a label and presentation, rather than reopening its historic distillery.[5]

Symbolic illustration: The blend moves forward
September 26, 2024

The blend moves forward

RCLR launched with two Kentucky bourbon batches. The first married younger wheated bourbon with older rye-recipe bourbons; the second developed a different balance. The range extended Rare Character’s work beyond individual casks into deliberately composed blends.[7]

Symbolic illustration: Old Cassidy gains an annual rhythm
October 2025

Old Cassidy gains an annual rhythm

The founders’ Wine Enthusiast interview identifies October 2025 as the introduction of the annual Old Cassidy blend. That edition used older Kentucky bourbon as its foundation. Later annual editions should be read on their own specifications.[9]

Symbolic illustration: A rye for the cocktail glass
November 2025

A rye for the cocktail glass

The same interview dates Hurst Knoll’s release to November 2025. The seven-year Kentucky rye at 101 proof offered a more repeatable cocktail role alongside the company’s highly limited single barrels and special releases.[9]

Symbolic illustration: Black Maple Hill returns to Kentucky
2026

Black Maple Hill returns to Kentucky

Rare Character revived Black Maple Hill around a Kentucky-focused range at 95 proof. The brand’s own press archive labels its announcement March 2026; a later Business Wire distribution appeared in July. Neither date makes the historic label a newly built distillery.[22][20]

Symbolic illustration: A new Old Cassidy composition
2026

A new Old Cassidy composition

The 2026 Old Cassidy release, A-026, combined Kentucky bourbons aged nine to nineteen years at 122.22 proof. It illustrates the annual format: continuity in name and intent, with a distinct composition and identity for each edition.[16]

Original watercolor interpretations accompany the history. Buildings, objects and scenes are symbolic, not documentary reconstructions.

03 / Geography & roles

One name. Several places that matter.

Symbolic Kentucky maturation warehouse and bottling workspace, not a literal facility

Kentucky

Maturation and bottling hub

The official FAQ describes further Kentucky aging and bottling after sourcing from several states. Lexington appears as a bottling location on current Hurst Knoll and Old Cassidy pages. These are distinct production roles. They do not identify every source distillery or establish a visitor center.[11][17]

Indiana and other source states

Release-specific whiskey origins

The barrel archive identifies HRC bourbon as distilled and aged in Indiana, with Canton cooperage. Other entries have their own state and cooperage information. A Kentucky bottler can therefore release whiskey with a different distillation or maturation history. Follow the specific barrel record when it is available.[12]

Los Angeles

Hospitality roots

Moix’s selections for Los Angeles bars and restaurants helped form the emphasis on individual preferences and exclusive barrels. That hospitality connection does not establish California distillation. A professional origin and a whiskey’s production origin are different things.[10]

04 / The whiskey family

Understand the name on the label.

Selected ownership, brand and creative relationships. The brand, its production partners and its expressions play different roles.

Symbolic family of selected whiskeys with different bottle and label forms

Single Barrel Series

Flagship selection program

The flagship framework centers on individual barrels and customer preferences. Bourbon, rye and finishes can sit beside one another without sharing a single recipe or distilling source.[2]

Exceptional Series and Gen3

Curation-focused ranges

The Exceptional range emphasizes older, scarce selections; its official overview states a minimum age of nine years. Gen3 has its own detailed bottle register. Neither title alone identifies a distillery or a universally shared recipe.[13]

Fortuna

Historic revival, introduced in 2022

The modern revival remains a documented part of Rare Character’s story and official archive. Andy Shapira’s role is recorded in the 2022 announcement. His family connection to Heaven Hill should not be converted into a supply claim or an assertion about today’s management.[4]

Brook Hill

Historic revival, introduced in 2024

The revived black-label range contains bourbon and rye selections with individual names, yields, proofs and ages. The archive demonstrates a family of specific releases rather than one uniform Brook Hill specification.[6]

Rare Character Limited Release

Limited batch blends

RCLR is the blending arm of the portfolio, with batches and annual artwork. Its current archive includes both Kentucky-only and multi-state bourbon descriptions, alongside rye releases. A batch number needs its year and whiskey type to be meaningful.[8]

Pride of Anderson County

Kentucky single-barrel project

The current official page describes a transition from lottery-only releases to a broader single-barrel series, beginning that chapter with nine-year Kentucky bourbon. The name does not disclose the source distillery.[18]

Old Cassidy and Hurst Knoll

Different roles within the current range

Old Cassidy carries an annual Kentucky blending concept. Hurst Knoll has a different purpose: a minimum seven-year, 101-proof Kentucky rye developed for cocktails. Their coexistence shows how the portfolio makes room for both special occasions and regular bar service.[16][17]

Black Maple Hill

Revived Kentucky-focused label

The current revival returns the name to Kentucky whiskey. Rare Character’s overview lists a 95-proof Kentucky straight bourbon and a sixteen-year expression; the 2026 announcement also includes an eleven-year bourbon. These are new chapters of an older sourced brand.[20]

Commander’s Club

One-time blend

Grand Cuvée Reserve is presented as a one-time Kentucky blend of ten- to fifteen-year barrels. Its 110.42-proof specification and 2,325-bottle yield belong to that release. The name should not be read as a separate owned distillery.[19]

Helmsman Imports

Documented commercial partner

Helmsman named Rare Character among its partners in an October 2025 announcement. That is a trade relationship. It does not make Helmsman the whiskey’s distiller or establish ownership of Rare Character.[23]

05 / Making & choosing

Selection first. Character follows.

Single-barrel selection, deliberate blending and distinct finishes shape this range. Production origins, ages and specifications belong to the releases named.

Symbolic individual cask sampling and tasting notebook

Select the whiskey before the label

The FAQ describes a barrel program open to qualifying businesses, groups, clubs and individuals. A rotating inventory allows a conversation about the desired whiskey rather than a fixed catalogue. Retail bottle availability is a separate matter from purchasing a whole barrel. Those two paths explain why a private selection may be found through a particular retailer rather than through the producer itself.[11]

A blend has its own architecture

The first RCLR blend used 5.5-year wheated Kentucky bourbon with eight- and fifteen-year rye-recipe bourbon. Those components contributed different qualities to a composed whiskey. Their ages and recipes belong to the batch, not the whole company.[7]

Wood is a separate decision

The barrel archive documents wine-cask finishes and native-wood experiments. Jaqueira-finished rye is one example, using a Brazilian wood associated with cachaça maturation. Such treatments belong to their named releases. A finished expression should be distinguished from an untreated barrel even when the base whiskey has a similar recipe.[12]

Age does not replace selection

Exceptional Series is positioned around curation, with at least nine years of age in the official overview. Age establishes time in wood, but the selection still rests on the individual whiskey. That distinction fits a portfolio where texture, concentration and balance vary by cask, and where the highest age is not a universal target for every release.[13]

Read the individual register

The Gen3 page lists bottles by letter and number, with separate proofs and yields. Some entries contain only a few dozen bottles. This granularity makes the exact designation useful: a broad range name is insufficient when comparing releases. The register does not explain every technical production step, so the name should not be used to invent one.[14]

06 / The details worth knowing

The stories behind the familiar name.

The barrel as a personal commission

Customized labels and a wax-color system give private selections a visible identity. Nevenglosky describes the business as curation; Moix tastes its barrels. Presentation connects a selection with a group or occasion, while the whiskey remains the foundation.[10]

Thirty-six bottles from an unlikely find

Moix told Wine Enthusiast that a fire-damaged California winery led him to older bourbon barrels, most effectively empty. He bought the lot after tasting the surviving whiskey; the find became Obliteration. The producer’s page records a 36-bottle release. The location and original distiller remain unnamed, so the story is retained as Moix’s account rather than filled in with conjecture.[9][15]

The llama joins the blend

The RCLR announcement explained its llama artwork as a tribute to a symbol familiar to followers. Planned variations connected the new blending range with that community. The image supplied visual continuity, rather than a promise of identical whiskey.[7]

An old name is not an old recipe

Black Maple Hill’s modern revival emphasizes its Kentucky identity after earlier Kentucky and Oregon periods. That history gives the name emotional weight, but it does not make today’s whiskey identical to a collectible bottling from another era. The current producer, release and label information are the useful anchors when comparing those chapters.[21]

07 / Selected expressions

Individual casks. Composed blends. Revived names.

A curated reading of the whiskey family, selected for its role in the story. This is not an exhaustive current catalog.

Brook Hill: a register of individual casks

The 2024 archive includes King’s Leap, a ten-year bourbon at 129.35 proof with a 102-bottle yield, and Bedlam, an eleven-year rye at 125.13 proof with 66 bottles. These examples show the program’s scale and variety. Distribution locations listed beside them should not be mistaken for where they were distilled.[6]

RCLR: a broader blending canvas

The 2026 RCLR narrative describes a Kentucky-and-Indiana bourbon composition spanning several ages, with time allowed for the barrels to marry. This is a different proposition from the initial Kentucky-only batches. The archive makes the continuing lesson clear: year, batch and whiskey category need to travel together when identifying a limited release.[8]

Old Cassidy A-026

The 2026 Kentucky bourbon blend spans nine to nineteen years, is bottled in Lexington at 122.22 proof and has a stated yield of 2,650 bottles. Its details belong to A-026. They should not be applied retroactively to the 2025 release or treated as a permanent recipe for future annual editions.[16]

Hurst Knoll

This minimum seven-year Kentucky straight rye is bottled at 101 proof. Moix designed it for drinks such as a Manhattan or Old Fashioned. It gives the portfolio a practical cocktail expression without requiring the drinker to chase a single exceptional cask. Its Kentucky production and Lexington bottling statements are specific to this whiskey.[17]

Commander’s Club Grand Cuvée Reserve

The official specification combines ten- to fifteen-year Kentucky whiskey at 110.42 proof, with 2,325 bottles. Rare Character describes the blend as a one-time composition. That makes the exact release name more useful than assumptions about a recurring house style, and separates it from the annual Old Cassidy format.[19]

08 / The Reserve connection

Continue from the story to the bottles.

Rare Character Whiskey in The Thelen Reserve

6 physical bottle records connect this story to the collection. Each keeps its own proof, barrel, batch, pick and release details.

Approved watercolor of Rare Character SB Bourbon CS Finished Madeira Casks

Rare Character SB Bourbon CS Finished Madeira Casks

W0377 · 112.68 proof · Barrel MADB-1 · Bottle 80 · Pick Seelbach · Bottled / release detail 4/2022

Approved watercolor of Rare Character SB Rye CS Finished White Port Casks

Rare Character SB Rye CS Finished White Port Casks

W0378 · 112.54 proof · Barrel WPR-61 · Bottle 8 · Pick Trevors · Bottled / release detail 10/2022

Approved watercolor of Rare Character Single Barrel Bourbon Cask Strength

Rare Character Single Barrel Bourbon Cask Strength

W0379 · 115.52 proof · Barrel RIO-202 · Pick Seelbach · Bottled / release detail Bottled May 2022 (label month/year only) · Barreled detail Label: distilled May 2016; exact day not given. Existing H May 1 is historical month placeholder; not independently verified barreling day. · Barreled 5/1/2016

Approved watercolor of Rare Character Single Barrel Bourbon Cask Strength - BJ's

Rare Character Single Barrel Bourbon Cask Strength - BJ's

W0380 · 117.86 proof · Barrel RIO-209 · Pick Bourbon Junkies · Bottled / release detail Bottled June 2022 (6/2022 on label); day not supplied. · Barreled detail Distilled May 2016 (5/2016 on label); day not supplied.

Approved watercolor of Rare Character Single Barrel Bourbon Finished in Maple Cask

Rare Character Single Barrel Bourbon Finished in Maple Cask

W0381 · 124.12 proof · Barrel MAP-B-459 · Bottle 34 · Bottled / release detail 07/2024; label BOTTLED 7-2024, month only, no day inferred. · Barreled detail Rear DISTILLED7-11-2016. Existing BARRELED ON7/11/2016 preserved as inventory legacy; actual barreling date not independently established. Front age8.1years as written. · Barreled 7/11/2016

Approved watercolor of Rare Character Single Barrel Rye Cask Strength - ADHD Fishing

Rare Character Single Barrel Rye Cask Strength - ADHD Fishing

W0382 · 121.2 proof · Barrel KRY-547 · Pick ADHD Fishing · Bottled / release detail Bottled 6/20/22, handwritten rear label; 6/20/2022 stored in bottled-date field. · Barreled detail DISTILLED handwritten date appears 1/20/16; kept as raw distilled-date evidence, not assumed barreling date. Front age6y6m vs apparent6y5m date span needs confirmation. Mash bill95/5 printed by hand. · Bottled / release 6/20/2022

Collection snapshot: October 22, 2026. Approved watercolor artwork appears where an exact record or verified release match is available. Separate physical bottles and release distinctions are preserved.

Rare Character Whiskey three-page guide cover
The illustrated companion

Rare Character Whiskey, in three pages.

Origins and people, history and places, whiskey and stories. The approved illustrated companion includes linked research sources.

Sources & research notes

Researched October 15, 2026. Official brand and company pages, dated announcements and clearly identified supporting sources are distinguished in the research. Product specifications are release- and market-specific.

Research qualifications

  • Researched October 15, 2026. Selected relationships and releases; the range is dynamic, not an exhaustive catalogue.
  • The first three timeline entries concern earlier label histories, not Rare Character company or facility operations.
  • Supplier identities are not inferred from mash bills, barrel codes, DSP addresses, friendship or a collaborator’s family background.
  • Symbolic artwork represents documented activities and label histories; it does not depict a confirmed facility or historical likeness.

Full sources

  1. Rare Character: About2020 idea, 2021 foundation, founders and complementary backgrounds. Note: Current official company history; not a complete ownership register or facility inventory.
  2. Rare Character: Single Barrel SeriesIndependent bottling model, rotating barrel menu and finishes. Note: Producer statement; specifications belong to the named release, not every Rare Character bottle.
  3. Fortuna relaunch announcement, September 20, 2022Fortuna history, Hollenbach research, Andy Shapira’s 2022 role and original six-year/102-proof blend. Note: Historical announcement; Shapira’s participation does not establish a current role or a Heaven Hill supply relationship.
  4. Rare Character: FortunaFortuna’s nineteenth-century origins and revival framing. Note: Undated official page; does not establish current availability or comprehensive legal ownership.
  5. Brook Hill revival announcement, March 14, 2024Friedman/Keiler history, 2024 revival and initial 10-year bourbon/11-year rye. Note: Rare Character announcement syndicated from GlobeNewswire; historic continuity is the brand’s account.
  6. Rare Character: Brook Hill2024 release archive, names, ages, proofs and yields. Note: Archive is labeled 2024; product state destinations are distribution, not distillation locations. Prohibition lore is not independently established here.
  7. RCLR launch announcement, September 26, 2024First RCLR batches, blend components and llama artwork. Note: Producer statement; specifications belong to the named release, not every Rare Character bottle.
  8. Rare Character: Limited ReleaseAnnual batch archive and 2026 Kentucky/Indiana blend explanation. Note: Dynamic page contains repeated batch numbers and mixed specifications. Use narrative description without attaching ambiguous specifications to a numbered 2026 batch.
  9. Wine Enthusiast: Rare Character founder interview, February 3, 2026Direct founders’ accounts of Obliteration, sourcing and October/November 2025 introductions. Note: First-person interview supports attributed anecdotes; fire site and original distillery remain unnamed.
  10. Garden & Gun: Four Under-the-Radar Whiskey Brands to KnowDirect Nevenglosky interview; Moix’s barrel tasting, private selections and wax profile system. Note: Use only Rare Character portion and direct founder testimony; wax color is not a universal source-distillery code.
  11. Rare Character: FAQMultiple-state sourcing, further Kentucky aging/bottling and barrel program participation. Note: Broad FAQ conflicts with some specific archive maturation/bottling entries. It is not universal historical proof for every bottle.
  12. Rare Character: Barrel BreakdownRelease-specific HRC Indiana history, cooperage, Jaqueira finishing and other barrel records. Note: A single page and shared copyright budget across all anchors. Barrel codes or mash bills do not independently identify an unnamed distillery.
  13. Rare Character: Exceptional SeriesCuration-focused range and stated minimum nine years. Note: Current range description, not a verified first-launch date.
  14. Rare Character: Exceptional Gen3Individually enumerated bottles, proofs and very small yields. Note: No publication date or full technical production explanation; do not infer a process from Gen3 naming.
  15. Rare Character: ObliterationProducer’s 36-bottle limited bourbon description. Note: Undated page; historical superlatives are the producer’s description when written, not an audited current record.
  16. Rare Character: Old Cassidy2026 blend, 9–19-year range, A-026, 122.22 proof and Lexington bottling. Note: Producer statement; specifications belong to the named release, not every Rare Character bottle.
  17. Rare Character: Hurst KnollMinimum seven-year Kentucky rye, 101 proof, cocktail purpose and Lexington bottling. Note: Page has an erroneous AGE: Kentucky field; prose supplies the minimum age.
  18. Rare Character: Pride of Anderson CountyLottery-to-market evolution, nine-year Kentucky single-barrel bourbon and cask-strength presentation. Note: Undated transition; not proof of a named Anderson County distiller or a new production facility.
  19. Rare Character: Commander’s ClubGrand Cuvée Reserve, 10–15-year Kentucky blend, 110.42 proof and 2,325 bottles. Note: One-time release; no verified launch date or parent-company acquisition.
  20. Rare Character: Black Maple HillCurrent Kentucky revival and initial 95-proof offerings. Note: Browser title incorrectly says Commander’s Club; visible body identifies Black Maple Hill.
  21. Black Maple Hill relaunch announcement, syndicated July 9, 20262000 origin, Oregon era, Rare Character revival and 95-proof Kentucky range. Note: Historical supplier claims include qualified speculation; omitted. July syndication is not the first revival date.
  22. Black Maple Hill: Official press archiveOfficial March 2026 press label and April 2026 Sotheby’s revival reference. Note: Dates distinguish initial revival from later syndication. Do not treat linked media speculation as ownership documentation.
  23. Helmsman Imports partner announcement, October 23, 2025Helmsman names Rare Character as a partner; distinguishes trade support from whiskey distillation. Note: Partner’s announcement, not proof of exclusive distribution, ownership or a particular operational service.
  24. Rare Character: Current offeringsCurrent range overview: single barrels, RCLR blends and historic revivals. Note: Dynamic promotional overview; individual product pages govern technical specifications.
↑