TJ THELEN'S COLLECTION
The Thelen Reserve
Behind the Bottles / Palisade, Colorado

Peach Street Distillers

Last updated Last researched

Orchard country, with bourbon in the cellar.

At the meeting of Colorado fruit country and the high desert, Peach Street built a distillery around what its neighbors could grow. Bourbon shares that story with pear brandy, grappa and a working tasting room. Founded in 2005, the Palisade producer now has a new local ownership chapter, while its older barrels preserve a longer view of the valley.[6][7][11]

Symbolic Palisade orchard, mesa, still and bourbon glass
Home
Palisade, Colorado[5]
Founded
2005[6][10]
Role
Working distillery[1]
Current operators
Cody & Michael Lewis[1]
01 / Origins & people

A stillhouse built around its neighbors.

A location chosen for its growers

Rory Donovan, Bill Graham and Dave Thibodeau brought brewing friendships and an interest in distilling to the project. In a 2013 interview, Donovan recalled a distilling workshop that helped turn experiments into a business plan. Palisade offered direct relationships with fruit growers and a reason to make more than one kind of spirit.[7]

The place comes before the product

A peach on the nameplate can make the bourbon seem like a side road. The wider range explains it better: fermentable fruit and grain were the raw materials for a small local distillery. The producer dates its founding to 2005; Donovan later recalled becoming operational with vodka and fruit spirits that August. A separate interview gives September for distilling, so the year is firmer than the month.[6][7][8]

Symbolic founders workbench and empty chairs

Rory Donovan

Co-founder and early public voice. His interviews supply the account of choosing Palisade, assembling equipment and building the early trade. These are attributed recollections rather than a complete corporate record.[7][8]

Bill Graham & Dave Thibodeau

Co-founders with connections to Ska Brewing in Durango. The brewing relationship belongs to the origin story and later beer-distillation experiments; it does not make every Peach Street whiskey a Ska beer distillate.[7][3]

Cody & Michael Lewis, Jesse & Desa Loughman

A 2025 operator interview names the four new co-owners. The current distillery site identifies Cody and Michael Lewis as the local owner-operators. Hospitality renewal is part of this chapter, alongside the continuing spirits business.[11][1]

02 / The illustrated history

From orchard harvest to a new local chapter.

Follow the founding, bourbon milestone, growing range and ownership changes. Dates retain their documented roles.

Symbolic illustration: A distillery takes root
2005

A distillery takes root

The producer establishes its Palisade story in 2005. Donovan later recalls an August start with vodka and fruit spirits, while another interview places distilling in September. Keep the common year without inventing one exact opening day.[6][7][8]

Symbolic illustration: Colorado bourbon reaches the glass
2008

Colorado bourbon reaches the glass

Contemporary August coverage records the bourbon introduction after more than two years in barrel. Peach Street describes its achievement as Colorado’s first legal bourbon after Prohibition. That specific bourbon claim is narrower than a claim to be the state’s first distillery.[14][12]

Symbolic illustration: The founder explains the work
2011

The founder explains the work

In a first-person bar interview, Donovan describes the early distilling years and a return to wholesaling bourbon. The account captures a small producer trying to balance making spirits, allocating aged stock and reaching customers.[8]

Symbolic illustration: Craft recognition broadens the audience
2012

Craft recognition broadens the audience

Contemporary reporting records American Distilling Institute Distillery of the Year recognition and medals across fruit spirits and bourbon. The breadth matters: Peach Street’s early reputation was built across the stillhouse, rather than on whiskey alone.[9]

Symbolic illustration: Growers and the tasting room support growth
2013

Growers and the tasting room support growth

Donovan’s May interview describes direct local sourcing, a busy seven-day tasting room and plans for surrounding property. It is a useful snapshot of how hospitality and production supported one another, not a claim that every planned expansion was completed.[7]

Symbolic illustration: Wine and bourbon trade barrels
2022

Wine and bourbon trade barrels

For September’s Wine Fest, Sauvage Spectrum and Peach Street introduce a reciprocal collaboration. The announcement identifies bourbon barrel 753, using three-year bourbon followed by six months in a wine-soaked cask. Those details describe that release.[10][13]

Symbolic illustration: A fresh local ownership chapter
2025

A fresh local ownership chapter

Cody Butters Lewis introduces the new co-owner group in a first-person interview: Cody and Mike Lewis with Jesse and Desa Loughman. Her account centers on rebuilding the gathering place and improving the visitor experience while respecting its history.[11]

Symbolic illustration: A working Palisade gathering place
2026 / current

A working Palisade gathering place

The current site presents onsite distillation, a daily tasting room, patio and food service, and identifies the Lewis family as local operators. This is the current operating picture checked in October 2026, not a new founding date.[1][5]

Original watercolor interpretations accompany the history. Buildings, objects and scenes are symbolic, not documentary reconstructions.

03 / Geography & roles

A working landscape, with distinct roles.

Interpretive Colorado Grand Valley orchard and river landscape

Palisade / Grand Valley

The home landscape and supplier community. Orchards, vineyards and local grains give the range a coherent setting even as individual recipes differ.[7][10]

144 S. Kluge Avenue, Building #2

The working distillery and visitor address. Tasting, tours, food and the patio share a destination; they are roles at a current site, not separate production facilities.[1][5]

Durango / Ska Brewing

A founding-personnel and beer collaboration connection. The current whiskey page describes distilling Modus Hoperandi IPA through a Christian Carl pot still and aging it in used bourbon barrels.[7][3]

Sauvage Spectrum / Palisade

A neighboring wine collaborator. The 2022 exchange connects Peach Street bourbon barrels, Devil’s Prey red wine and a finished bourbon, without implying common ownership.[10]

04 / The whiskey family

Understand the name on the label.

Selected ownership, site and production relationships. Corporate links do not make every whiskey the same release.

Peach Street Distillers

Producer / facility

The producer identity and Palisade working distillery. Its bourbon sits within a wider fruit-and-grain spirits business.[1][4]

Original founding team

Historical people

Donovan, Graham and Thibodeau belong to the founding account, distinct from today’s owner-operator description.[7][11]

Lewis & Loughman group

Current ownership chapter

The 2025 interview identifies four new co-owners; current official copy names Cody and Michael Lewis as local operators. Legal entity and exact closing day are not independently established here.[11][1]

Ska Brewing

Historical / product collaboration

Founding friendships and a named IPA distillation experiment. It is a specific relationship, not a blanket source for the bourbon range.[7][3]

Sauvage Spectrum

Independent collaborator

The wine partner in a documented 2022 barrel exchange. Barrel 753 and its finish remain release-specific.[10]

Orchard and grain growers

Agricultural network

Suppliers and local relationships central to the original location choice. Fruit brandies, grappa and grain whiskey make different uses of the valley’s harvest.[7][4]

05 / Making & choosing

The recipe is only the beginning.

Grain, fruit, distillation and oak each have a role. Specifications below belong to the editions named.

Symbolic copper pot still and grain scoop

Grain and fruit have different jobs

The current producer describes local grains, fruit and Rocky Mountain water, with onsite distillation in Palisade. Fruit brandy is made from fermented fruit; that does not mean the standard bourbon is peach flavored.[1][4]

Bourbon, with edition-specific ages

The bourbon page presents a three-year standard expression, older single barrels, bonded bourbon and other variations. Its broad introduction also says a minimum of two years. Read the named expression and its label rather than flattening the range to one age.[2]

Distilling beer is a separate experiment

The Modus Hoperandi entry describes taking Ska’s IPA through a Christian Carl pot still, then aging in second-use bourbon barrels. Hops and used oak distinguish this account from the standard bourbon story.[3]

Oak can hold a conversation

The 2022 wine collaboration sent bourbon barrels to red wine, then used wine-soaked oak for bourbon. Its announced six-month finish differs from today’s portfolio description of one year or more. They are retained as different release descriptions.[10][2]

Barrel proof and bonded proof

The current range describes barrel strength around 117 proof, while its four-year bonded expression is listed at 100 proof. Neither specification establishes the proof or age of an older private barrel selection.[2]

Recipe limits are part of the record

A historical 2008 local report describes 60 percent corn. This profile does not treat that as a verified current recipe. The whiskey page also pairs an American Single Malt image with rye copy, so that conflicting description is excluded rather than silently repaired.[14][3]

06 / The details worth knowing

The details that change the story.

Symbolic Palisade fruit harvest still life

The peach is a place, not a universal flavor

The name belongs to a fruit-growing town. The line includes actual fruit brandies, while a separate peach-infused bourbon uses a peach-brandy barrel and dried fruit. Standard bourbon and the infused expression should remain distinct.[4][2]

A bourbon first, carefully worded

The distillery’s post-Prohibition bourbon claim is a recurring part of its identity. It should be attributed and kept specific. The evidence here supports the 2008 bourbon milestone, while early operating recollections vary by month and some older coverage uses 2004 shorthand.[12][14][7][8][9]

A tasting room can finance a stillhouse

Donovan’s 2013 account connects tasting-room activity to growth. The later operator interview returns to the importance of making the place welcoming to locals. Across the two chapters, hospitality is part of the business model and the story.[7][11]

A valley with more than one harvest

Fruit brandies, pomace grappa and grain whiskey put different agricultural materials to work. The current portfolio’s use of local grape pomace gives the wine connection another dimension beyond borrowed barrels.[4]

The shared barrel has a number

Barrel 753 makes the 2022 collaboration unusually tangible. The announcement ties a specific bourbon barrel to a specific event and finish. That precision is useful because it prevents a later finished bourbon from being treated as an identical release.[10]

New operators, continuing stock

The current owner-operator chapter does not reset the age of spirits already maturing. A whiskey’s distillation, maturation and bottling dates can cross ownership periods. This is a reading principle; exact custody of individual historical casks is not documented here.[11][2]

Symbolic charred oak barrel and tasting glasses
07 / Selected expressions

Different methods. Distinct expressions.

A curated reading of the whiskey family, selected for its role in the story. This is not an exhaustive current catalog.

Colorado Straight Bourbon

The core bourbon is the historical anchor. The current page describes a minimum three-year expression; older reporting captures the 2008 introduction. Proof and age must be read from the relevant edition.[2][14]

Older single barrels & bonded bourbon

The current portfolio spans five-plus and seven-plus single barrels, a ten-year expression listed at 110 proof and a four-year bonded bourbon at 100 proof. These illustrate selection and maturation choices rather than one uniform bottling.[2]

Wine-finished & peach-infused bourbon

Two distinct ways to return the whiskey to its agricultural surroundings. Wine-seasoned oak changes the finish; the peach expression adds a peach-brandy cask and dried Palisade peaches. Keep both distinct from unflavored straight bourbon.[2][10]

Rye, smoke & beer distillate

The whiskey family extends beyond bourbon through rye, smoked rye, peated barley whiskey and the Modus Hoperandi experiment. The producer page’s conflicting single-malt/rye entry remains qualified, not used as a dependable recipe.[3]

08 / The Reserve connection

Continue from the story to the bottles.

Peach Street Distillers in The Thelen Reserve

1 physical bottle record connects this story to the collection. Each keeps its own proof, barrel, batch, pick and release details.

Approved watercolor of Peach Street Colorado Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Peach Street Colorado Straight Bourbon Whiskey

W0357 · 92 proof · Barrel 393 · Pick Total Wine CO

Barrel 393 · Total Wine CO pick. Bottle number, batch, age and dates are not recorded.

Collection snapshot: October 26, 2026. One physical record, with its recorded barrel and pick details preserved.

Peach Street Distillers three-page guide cover
The illustrated companion

Peach Street Distillers, in three pages.

Origins and people, history and places, whiskey and stories. A concise companion to this full profile, with linked research sources.

Sources & research notes

Researched October 20, 2026. Primary producer announcements and institutional records are used wherever available. Product specifications are release- and market-specific.

Research qualifications

  • Research checked October 20, 2026. Current producer descriptions and dated first-person accounts are distinguished. Sources include attributed historical reporting where primary contemporary release documents were not available.
  • Founding year is 2005. August and September operating recollections differ; a 2012 report uses 2004 shorthand. No exact founding day is asserted.
  • The first-bourbon statement is attributed to Peach Street and confined to post-Prohibition Colorado bourbon. It is not a verified universal first-distillery claim.
  • Current local owner-operators and the four co-owners named in the 2025 interview are separate from the founding team. Exact legal entity, acquisition closing day and continuing founders’ interests are not established.
  • The 2022 wine finish was six months on barrel 753; the current portfolio describes a later or differently specified one-year-plus finish. They are not assumed identical.
  • The whiskey page contains mismatched American Single Malt/rye copy. No unsupported recipe is supplied to resolve it. Historical corn percentages and current portfolio ages are not assigned to an unidentified older bottling.
  • Watercolor scenes are symbolic interpretations, including architecture, objects and people represented by empty chairs. They are not historical photographs or exact facility diagrams.

Full sources

  1. Peach Street Distillers: current homeCurrent local operators, onsite production statement and working distillery address.
  2. Producer bourbon portfolioCurrent selected bourbon ages, barrel strength, bonded and finished expressions. Specifications belong to listed editions.
  3. Producer whiskey portfolioRye, peated barley whiskey, smoked rye and Modus Hoperandi distillation. One American Single Malt entry has conflicting rye copy; do not repeat that recipe.
  4. Producer spirits familyFruit brandy, eau de vie, grappa, gin and vodka relationships. Broad production statements are producer claims.
  5. Visit the working distilleryPalisade address, patio, tours, food and community role.
  6. Producer media archiveProducer dates its origins to 2005; links to historical and ownership coverage.
  7. Founder interview: the proof is in the fruitMay 21, 2013 first-person founder recollections: Donovan, Graham, Thibodeau, August 2005 operations, grower-led location choice and tasting-room growth.
  8. Ask the bartender: Rory Donovan2011 first-person founder interview, September 2005 distilling recollection and bourbon distribution. Month differs from 2013 account.
  9. ADI Distillery of the Year reportContemporary 2012 award report and founder remarks. Its 2004 start shorthand conflicts with later founder account and producer founding year.
  10. Sauvage Spectrum collaboration announcementSeptember 2022 producer publicist release: reciprocal wine/bourbon barrels; barrel 753, three-year bourbon plus six-month finish.
  11. A Fresh Start: Cody Butters Lewis interview2025 first-person operator interview names Cody and Mike Lewis with Jesse and Desa Loughman and describes hospitality renewal.
  12. Celebrating Repeal DayDecember 5, 2025 producer account of post-Prohibition bourbon milestone. Superlative retained as attribution.
  13. 2022 collaboration industry releaseDated September 21, 2022 republication of producer announcement; corroborates collaboration chronology.
  14. Colorado bourbon introduction: contemporary archiveAugust 2008 local archive reproduces announcement and local reporting about first bourbon after more than two years. Secondary historical evidence, not a current recipe specification.
↑