TJ THELEN'S COLLECTION
The Thelen Reserve
Behind the Bottles / Colorado / American whiskey

Old
Elk

Last updated Last researched

The recipe, the grain, the patient cut

Colorado imagination. A distiller’s long view.

Old Elk began with a recipe and the patience to let it mature. Colorado enterprise and Greg Metze’s grain expertise built a whiskey family now owned by Ohio’s Middle West Spirits. Following the liquid reveals a richer story than a single pin on a map.[3][17]

Symbolic Colorado elk, malted barley, foothills and whiskey glass
Founded
Fort Collins · 2013[5]
Current owner
Middle West Spirits · since 2025[1]
Signature idea
High malt & Slow Cut[22]
Production history
Partner distillation & blending[7][8]
01 / Origins & people

A new recipe. Experienced hands.

A different kind of starting point

Curt and Nancy Richardson brought an entrepreneurial background to spirits. Their 2017 launch announcement connects them with OtterBox and Blue Ocean Enterprises. The whiskey venture’s ambition was to build a distinctive liquid and a lasting identity, rather than make the bottle’s home address do all the storytelling.[4]

Recipe first, inventory next

Then-CEO Luis Gonzalez’s 2020 account describes investing in custom recipes and maturing stock before a large-scale distillery. Indiana’s MGP supplied capacity beyond the small Colorado operation.[7]

Symbolic hands arranging a whiskey tasting

Greg Metze

Recipe architect / Master Distiller

A chemical engineer by training, Metze built his career at the Lawrenceburg, Indiana distillery historically associated with Seagram. His official biography traces a path through supervision, engineering and production to master distiller in 2002. Old Elk gave that long technical apprenticeship a named creative platform.[2]

Melinda Maddox

Master Blender / finishing voice

Maddox brought a bartender’s understanding of how flavors meet into production. The 2023 Island Blend announcement credits her with blending, bottling and the Single Barrel program. By the 2024 Cognac Wheat release, the company identifies her as Master Blender, shaping a second creative voice alongside Metze’s recipes.[14][15]

Luis Gonzalez & Ryan Lang

Brand continuity / owner’s leadership

Gonzalez helped build Old Elk’s national business and became Middle West’s Chief Commercial Officer in August 2025. Middle West founder and CEO Ryan Lang represents the Ohio production organization now behind the brand’s next chapter.[17]

02 / The illustrated history

An idea that keeps finding new expressions.

Follow the custom recipes, the people and the changing production relationships. Founding, distilling, release and ownership dates describe different chapters.

Symbolic illustration: A Colorado whiskey venture begins
2013

A Colorado whiskey venture begins

Old Elk’s company story starts in Fort Collins. The Richardson-backed project gives a modern Colorado setting to an ambition that depends on years of inventory planning before a national whiskey portfolio can emerge.[5]

Symbolic illustration: A signature recipe is commissioned
2013

A signature recipe is commissioned

The founder approaches Metze to develop the flagship mash bill. This is the recipe relationship, preceding his later move to Old Elk as an employee. A generous malted-barley share becomes the bourbon’s distinguishing starting point.[3]

Symbolic illustration: Metze joins the Old Elk team
2016

Metze joins the Old Elk team

After a long Indiana career, Metze becomes Old Elk’s Master Distiller. The person who helped create the liquid can now help guide the brand built around it.[3]

Symbolic illustration: The flagship reaches its launch chapter
December 6, 2017

The flagship reaches its launch chapter

A dated company announcement introduces Blended Straight Bourbon alongside a seasonal Nooku cream release. Old Elk is a spirits business with several expressions, with high malt and gradual proofing giving the bourbon its own identity.[4]

Symbolic illustration: The Reserve opens in Old Town
August 2018

The Reserve opens in Old Town

The tasting room and eatery brings the portfolio into a Fort Collins social setting. A September announcement reports expansion from two states to 21, linking a local gathering place with a growing national business.[5]

Symbolic illustration: Sour Mash Reserve takes another route
March 1, 2021

Sour Mash Reserve takes another route

The first lot uses the familiar high-malt grain proportions but is distilled in New York with a proprietary yeast blend. Thirty-barrel lots make variation part of the idea. A shared recipe does not require a shared distillery.[8]

Symbolic illustration: The Master’s Blend range widens
April 4, 2022

The Master’s Blend range widens

Four Grain and Double Wheat join Metze’s blending series. Established whiskey categories become ingredients for new combinations, extending the creative work beyond the original flagship.[10]

Symbolic illustration: Infinity carries a previous chapter forward
November 2022

Infinity carries a previous chapter forward

The second annual Infinity Blend retains some of the 2021 edition, adding Old Elk bourbon, wheat whiskey and mature Kentucky bourbon. Announced November 16 for November 18 availability, it makes continuity a physical part of the blend.[11]

Symbolic illustration: Rum casks give rye another voice
January 19, 2023

Rum casks give rye another voice

The company introduces its first national rye release finished in Barbados rum casks. Returning Port and Cognac bourbon finishes place it within a broader secondary-maturation program.[12]

Symbolic illustration: Barrel selection becomes hands-on
April 12, 2023

Barrel selection becomes hands-on

A company account describes customers sampling barrels, drawing whiskey and learning bottling or labeling steps. The selected cask, rather than a standard batch recipe, becomes the center of the experience.[13]

Symbolic illustration: Maddox builds the Island Blend
October 11, 2023

Maddox builds the Island Blend

Cigar Cut Island blends cask-finished bourbon, rye and wheat whiskey with Port, Sauternes, Sherry and Rum influences. The company credits Maddox with the release and describes her growing role in liquid development.[14]

Symbolic illustration: Wheat whiskey meets Cognac oak
August 19, 2024

Wheat whiskey meets Cognac oak

Maddox’s finishing program introduces a six-year wheat whiskey with additional maturation in French Limousine Cognac casks. The base grain and secondary vessel offer two separate layers to follow.[15]

Symbolic illustration: The everyday flagship evolves
February 27, 2025

The everyday flagship evolves

Slow Cut Blended Straight Bourbon pairs a four-to-seven-year high-malt foundation with selected straight bourbons. At 88 proof, the updated blend is positioned for cocktails and everyday occasions. Its full blend should not be reduced to one component recipe.[16]

Symbolic illustration: Old Elk joins Middle West Spirits
May 13, 2025

Old Elk joins Middle West Spirits

The Ohio distiller announces its acquisition of Old Elk and related assets. The pairing brings Old Elk’s blending identity together with Middle West’s production infrastructure. Existing aged whiskey retains its actual historical origin.[1]

Symbolic illustration: Commercial leadership carries forward
August 20, 2025

Commercial leadership carries forward

Former Old Elk CEO Gonzalez becomes Middle West’s Chief Commercial Officer. His expanded remit includes branded growth, operations, marketing and the owner’s contract-distillation business.[17]

Symbolic illustration: A new-fill partnership looks ahead
September 3, 2025

A new-fill partnership looks ahead

Barrel Global announces Old Elk wheated-bourbon new-fill barrels through Middle West. This is a future maturation program with its own recipe, not a claim that already-aged bottles were newly distilled in Ohio.[18]

Symbolic illustration: A decade collection arrives
July 28, 2026

A decade collection arrives

Middle West announces ten-year Straight Bourbon, Wheated Bourbon and Straight Wheat Whiskey. These are the first major new releases it announces for Old Elk after the acquisition, drawing the story back to patient inventory development.[19]

Original watercolor interpretations accompany the history. Buildings, objects and scenes are symbolic, not documentary reconstructions.

03 / Geography & roles

One name. Several places that matter.

Symbolic Colorado and Ohio composite landscape; not a literal map

Fort Collins, Colorado

Founding home / brand development

The brand’s founding home and the setting for its local production and hospitality chapter. Colorado identity should not automatically become a Colorado-distilled claim for every whiskey carrying the elk.[5][7]

Lawrenceburg, Indiana

Distilling expertise / historical supply

Metze’s professional roots and the MGP custom-production relationship belong here. The executive’s account identifies the partner; individual releases require their own provenance.[2][7]

New York

Release-specific distillation

The 2021 Sour Mash Reserve announcement explicitly places its first lot’s distillation in New York. The source facility is not named, so the geographic distinction is preserved without guessing a producer.[8]

The Reserve, Old Town

Historical hospitality space

The 2018 tasting-room project translated whiskey into a place for cocktails and conversation. Salt Design describes balancing industrial features with existing architecture. It is presented here as a historical chapter, not a current invitation to visit. Its designer describes an intimate space where the contrasting shapes of the spirit bottles informed the room’s character, making packaging part of the hospitality story.[6]

Columbus, Ohio

Current owner / production platform

Middle West supplies the current ownership and production-infrastructure context. Its Columbus distilleries, grain handling and maturation capability inform future development; they do not rewrite where older Old Elk stock originated.[1]

04 / The whiskey family

Understand the name on the label.

Selected ownership, brand and creative relationships. The brand, its production partners and its expressions play different roles.

Botanical grain family with corn, malted barley, rye and wheat

Middle West Spirits → Old Elk

Current ownership

The May 2025 transaction is an ownership acquisition. It differs from the historical supply relationships that helped build Old Elk’s inventory.[17]

MGP → commissioned whiskey

Historical contract production

Gonzalez identifies the Indiana partner used to scale commissioned recipes. A brand can direct a mash bill’s development while another company performs distillation.[7]

Metze + Maddox → a broader palette

Recipe / blending collaboration

Metze’s base recipes and Maddox’s finishing and blending decisions form complementary parts of the portfolio. The 2024 release explicitly credits the cask program to Maddox.[15]

Old Elk → Master’s Blend

Selected blending family

Four Grain and Double Wheat combine existing categories of whiskey into new compositions. A blend’s resulting grain percentages describe the assembled liquid, not necessarily a single four-grain fermentation.[10]

Old Elk → earlier sibling spirits

Historical related brands

Nooku bourbon cream and Dry Town gin appear alongside the flagship in early announcements. Whiskeysmith later adds flavored American whiskey. These historical associations do not establish that every sibling brand transferred to Middle West.[4][9]

Old Elk + Folds of Honor

Purpose-led whiskey partnership

A current 94-proof blended whiskey supports the organization’s educational-scholarship mission for families of fallen or disabled service members and first responders. It is labeled American whiskey, not assumed to be bourbon.[25]

05 / Making & choosing

Recipes, selection and a slower cut.

Custom grain recipes, blending and gradual proof reduction shape the whiskey. Source partners, age statements and finishing specifications belong to the releases named.

Symbolic gradual water addition during proofing

Give malt a leading role

The signature high-malt bourbon recipe is 51% corn, 34% malted barley and 15% rye. Corn still leads, while malt becomes an unusually substantial component. The proportions explain a recipe, not every component in every later blended bottling.[8]

Take proofing slowly

Old Elk describes Slow Cut as adding small increments of water over weeks. The stated aim is to manage heat and retain delicate flavor during dilution. This is the producer’s explanation of its method, rather than a universal guarantee that slower proofing improves every whiskey.[22]

Follow the specific grain bill

Current Straight Wheat Whiskey is described as 96% soft red winter wheat and 4% malted barley. A wheat-led whiskey and a wheated bourbon occupy different grain structures. Names that sound similar can therefore point to substantially different liquids.[21]

A second cask adds another layer

The current Port Bourbon page describes a five-to-six-year bourbon base followed by ten to twelve months in Port casks. Cognac Wheat begins with six years before another six to twelve months. Primary age and finishing duration should remain separate.[23]

Blend after each cask has spoken

Punch Cut Vol. 1 combines bourbon finished in Armagnac and Oloroso Sherry with wheat whiskey finished in Tawny Port and Sauternes. Each component matures and finishes separately before assembly, giving the blender several distinct voices to balance.[23]

Keep future whiskey distinct from aged stock

The 2025 Barrel Global announcement specifies new-fill wheated bourbon at 51% corn, 45% wheat and 4% malted barley. That program’s recipe is not the 2026 ten-year wheated bourbon recipe, and new make cannot supply a decade of aging overnight.[18]

06 / The details worth knowing

The stories behind the familiar name.

A career becomes a visible signature

Metze’s biography describes decades of work across bourbon, rye and other spirits. Old Elk puts that experience in the foreground: the recipe maker’s career becomes part of how drinkers understand the brand, rather than remaining invisible behind another label.[2]

The infinity idea is literal

The 2022 Infinity recipe retains 18% of the 2021 blend. Other components include seven-year Old Elk whiskey and twelve- and thirteen-year Kentucky bourbons. The previous release is an ingredient, giving the annual name a tangible connection to what came before.[11]

A selection can change direction

The 2023 Single Barrel account describes visitors arriving with one whiskey type in mind and choosing another after tasting. Its appeal lies in discovery across barrels and categories, rather than simply adding a private label to a predetermined bottle.[13]

Cigar Cut contains no tobacco

The company explicitly says its Cigar Cut blends contain neither tobacco nor nicotine. The name refers to pairing and occasion. Finishing casks create the whiskey’s character; a cigar on a label does not describe an ingredient.[24]

The bartender’s eye moves upstream

Maddox’s Island Blend shows a flavor professional moving from serving whiskey into authoring it. The company describes attention to drinkers’ seasonal preferences and a blend designed around a mood, adding another way to organize the cask inventory.[14]

A long story can change its home

The 2026 collection arrives after the brand joins Middle West, but its decade of maturation necessarily reaches back before that transaction. The owner’s new chapter and the whiskey’s earlier years coexist in the same bottle.[19]

Rye travels through a different cask

The 2023 Barbados Rum Cask release sits beside a separate Martinique-rum single-barrel offering mentioned later that spring. Those island references identify different finishing contexts. Neither gives permission to guess the rum distillery or combine both releases into one specification.[12][13]

07 / Selected expressions

Different grains. Different directions.

A curated reading of the whiskey family, selected for its role in the story. This is not an exhaustive current catalog.

Slow Cut Blended Straight Bourbon

The current 88-proof flagship is the approachable introduction to the brand. The 2025 announcement describes an evolved blend with a high-malt foundation and selected straight bourbons. Earlier bottlings should retain their own labels and specifications.[16][21]

Wheat-led expressions

Current Slow Cut Wheated Bourbon is 92 proof; Straight Wheat Whiskey is 100 proof. They provide contrasting ways to explore wheat’s role, without collapsing the bourbon and wheat-whiskey categories into one expression.[21]

Four Grain & Double Wheat

The 2022 Four Grain combines grain influences at 105.9 proof; Double Wheat joins wheat whiskey with wheated bourbon at 107.1 proof. Those launch specifications belong to those editions, not every subsequent bottle.[10]

Cask Finish & Cigar Cut

Port Bourbon, Cognac Wheat and the Cigar Cut blends show secondary maturation and assembly as separate creative tools. The original Cigar Cut concept includes Sherry, Armagnac, Port and Cognac influences; Island and Punch Cut are distinct editions.[23][24]

The 2026 Ten-Year Collection

Straight Bourbon and Wheated Bourbon are 105 proof; Straight Wheat Whiskey is 103 proof. The official collection page specifies 46% wheat for the wheated bourbon and 96% wheat for the wheat whiskey, preserving clear distinctions within the trio.[20]

Folds of Honor American Whiskey

At 94 proof, this blended whiskey links the portfolio with an educational-scholarship partnership. The official page establishes its category and purpose without disclosing a complete mash bill or a precise donation per bottle.[25]

08 / The Reserve connection

Continue from the story to the bottles.

Old Elk in The Thelen Reserve

6 physical bottle records connect this story to the collection. Each keeps its own proof, barrel, batch, pick and release details.

Approved watercolor of Old Elk Blended Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Old Elk Blended Straight Bourbon Whiskey

W0336 · 88 proof · Bottled / release detail Blended Straight Bourbon Whiskey; aged five years per back label; 88 proof / 44% ABV / 750 mL; bottled by Old Elk Distillery, Fort Collins, Colorado. No exact release/bottling date or batch specified. · Barreled detail Five-year age statement; exact barreling date not supplied. Matching expression review reports high-malt mash bill: 51% corn, 34% malted barley, 15% rye. Not a barrel-specific verification.

Approved watercolor of Old Elk Double Wheat

Old Elk Double Wheat

W0337 · 107.1 proof

Approved watercolor of Old Elk Four Grain

Old Elk Four Grain

W0338 · 105.9 proof

Approved watercolor of Old Elk Infinity Blend 2021

Old Elk Infinity Blend 2021

W0339 · 114.9 proof · Bottled / release detail 2021 release explicitly printed on blend-detail label. Release reported as December 2021 by the cited exact-edition review; exact bottling day unknown. Purchase occurred October 2022 and is preserved.

Approved watercolor of Old Elk Straight Wheat Whiskey

Old Elk Straight Wheat Whiskey

W0340 · 100 proof · Bottled / release detail Straight Wheat Whiskey; aged six years per back label; 100 proof / 50% ABV / 750 mL. Distilled in Indiana; bottled by Old Elk Distillery, Fort Collins, Colorado. Exact release/bottling date and batch unknown. · Barreled detail Back label: 95% winter wheat / 5% malted barley; six years aged. Exact barreling date not provided.

Approved watercolor of Old Elk Blended Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Old Elk Blended Straight Bourbon Whiskey

W0518 · 88 proof · Bottled / release detail Blended Straight Bourbon Whiskey; aged five years on back label; 88 proof / 44% ABV / 750 mL; bottled by Old Elk Distillery, Fort Collins, Colorado. Exact release/bottling date and batch not supplied. · Barreled detail Five-year age statement; exact barreling date not supplied. Matching expression review reports 51% corn, 34% malted barley, 15% rye. Expression-level evidence, not barrel-specific verification.

Collection snapshot: October 22, 2026. Approved watercolor artwork appears where an exact record or verified release match is available. Separate physical bottles and release distinctions are preserved.

Collection notes

Six physical bottles across five mapped releases connect this story to the collection. W0336 and W0518 are confirmed copies of the same 88-proof expression; their photos and statuses remain separate.

Collection snapshot: October 22, 2026. All six records have complete photo pairs. Five approved release artworks cover the collection, with the confirmed R0336 artwork shared by W0336 and W0518. Infinity W0339 remains the 2021 edition; W0340 retains its verified six-year 95/5 wheat recipe. These older bottle identities are not replaced by newer product specifications.

Old Elk three-page guide cover
The illustrated companion

Old Elk, in three pages.

Origins and people, history and places, whiskey and stories. The approved illustrated companion includes linked research sources.

Sources & research notes

Researched October 14, 2026. Official brand and company pages, dated announcements and clearly identified supporting sources are distinguished in the research. Product specifications are release- and market-specific.

Research qualifications

  • Founded in 2013 refers to the modern Fort Collins venture. No continuous nineteenth-century Old Elk lineage or trademark-revival narrative is asserted without primary documentation.
  • The 2013 Metze recipe commission precedes his 2016 employment. The December 2017 flagship announcement is a separate event from both.
  • Historical MGP production and the New York-distilled first Sour Mash lot are distinct; neither source explains every bottle.
  • The Reserve opened in August 2018. Current operation is not established by its historical project archive or 2023 barrel-experience release. No present-day booking or opening claim is made.
  • Middle West’s May 2025 acquisition is current ownership evidence. Historical Nooku, Dry Town and Whiskeysmith portfolio references are not treated as proof that all those brands were included in the transaction.
  • The 2026 launch prose conflicts with its technical figures. The official collection confirms 96% wheat whiskey and 46% wheated bourbon.
  • New-fill 2025 wheated bourbon is specified separately as 51/45/4. Do not apply that recipe, or current web recipes, retroactively to older bottles or other releases.
  • Slow Cut flavor-retention explanations are attributed to Old Elk. Exact sensory results and all claimed scientific mechanisms were not independently tested.
  • All original watercolor scenes are symbolic interpretations, not documentary photographs, exact historical architecture or verified portraits.

Full sources

  1. Middle West acquisition announcement, May 13, 2025Ownership acquisition; 2013 founding; Richardson founders; Ohio production context. Note: Existing aged stock retains its historical distillation origin.
  2. Greg Metze: official biography38-year Lawrenceburg career, chemical engineering degree in 1978, master distiller in 2002. Note: Historical official biography retrieved through search; direct URL returned 404 on October 14, 2026.
  3. Greg Metze recognition and recipe history, March 1, 2024Supplier announcement dates the recipe commission to 2013 and employment to 2016. Note: The commission predates employment.
  4. Flagship introduction, December 6, 2017Dated flagship introduction, Richardson founders and historical sibling spirits. Note: Launch and incorporation are distinct.
  5. Distribution and The Reserve, September 4, 2018Supplier announcement: August 2018 tasting-room opening and 21-state presence. Note: Historical, not current visitor information.
  6. Salt Design: The Reserve at 253 LindenDesigner account of the 2018 Fort Collins tasting-room transformation and interior design. Note: Project archive, not current visitor information.
  7. Luis Gonzalez: direct interview, October 22, 2020CEO describes MGP custom production and limited Colorado capacity. Note: Historical interview; recipe transcript error corrected against official specifications.
  8. Sour Mash Reserve first lot, March 1, 2021First lot distilled in New York; proprietary yeast; thirty-barrel batches; high-malt recipe. Note: Source distillery unnamed.
  9. Whiskeysmith national launch, September 27, 2021Historical related flavored-whiskey brand, real American whiskey and natural flavors. Note: Historical portfolio association does not establish which additional brands transferred in the 2025 acquisition.
  10. Four Grain and Double Wheat, April 4, 2022Master’s Blend releases, component categories, ages and composite grain proportions. Note: Composite blend proportions are not evidence that four grains fermented together.
  11. 2022 Infinity Blend, November 16, 2022Second annual release, November 18 availability, 18% prior 2021 blend, wheat and Kentucky bourbon components. Note: Recipe applies to 2022 only, not every Infinity edition.
  12. Barbados Rum Cask Rye, January 19, 2023Dated first national Barbados-rum-finished rye release alongside returning Port/Cognac bourbon finishes. Note: Do not guess the Barbados rum producer; Martinique single-barrel selections are separate.
  13. Single Barrel Experience, April 12, 2023Barrel sampling, selection, bottling/label participation, custom topper, historical tasting-room role and staff responsibilities. Note: Program described as of 2023; no promise of current Colorado appointments.
  14. Cigar Cut Island Blend, October 11, 2023Maddox-led blending, production responsibilities, six-year-plus bases and four cask types. Note: 2023 title was production manager and apprentice; later Master Blender title separately verified.
  15. Cognac Cask Finish Wheat, August 19, 2024First wheat Cognac finish, Maddox Master Blender, six-year base plus 6–12-month finish, 95 proof. Note: French Limousine spelling follows issuer. Do not substitute a named Cognac house.
  16. Slow Cut flagship evolution, February 27, 202588-proof core blend evolves: 4–7-year high-malt bourbon base plus selected straight bourbons. Note: Not a claim that every component or historical bottle has one mash bill or age.
  17. Luis Gonzalez becomes Middle West CCO, August 20, 2025Former Old Elk CEO appointed Middle West CCO, overseeing commercial, operational and marketing functions. Note: Current role differs from earlier CEO title.
  18. Barrel Global new-fill partnership, September 3, 2025Partner announces Old Elk wheated-bourbon new-fill barrels through Middle West, 51/45/4 recipe. Note: New-fill program recipe differs from 2026 ten-year recipe; not a review or recommendation of barrel ownership.
  19. Ten-Year Collection launch, July 28, 2026Dated launch; three ten-year whiskeys; technical recipes and proofs. Note: Conflicting prose is checked against technical figures and the official collection page.
  20. Official Ten-Year CollectionCurrent three expressions: 105-proof bourbon, 105-proof wheated bourbon with 46% wheat, 103-proof wheat with 96% wheat. Note: Current release specifications do not retroactively change older labels.
  21. Current core lineup88-proof Slow Cut Bourbon, 92-proof wheated bourbon, 100-proof wheat whiskey, current wheat recipe 96/4. Note: Current web lineup is a selected merchandising view, not an exhaustive historical release list.
  22. Old Elk: Slow Cut methodProducer describes adding water in small increments over weeks before bottling. Note: Flavor-retention and temperature benefits are the brand’s explanation, not an independently measured universal rule.
  23. Current Cask Finish SeriesPort Bourbon, Cognac Wheat and Punch Cut; separate base ages, finish duration and blend components. Note: Accolades on reused web panels are not used to date first releases.
  24. Cigar Cut: official conceptFinishing family, pairing concept and explicit absence of tobacco or nicotine in the whiskey. Note: No tobacco infusion; each edition has its own cask composition.
  25. Folds of Honor American WhiskeyCurrent 94-proof blended whiskey partnership supporting educational scholarships. Note: No unsupported launch date, per-bottle donation amount or bourbon designation.
↑