TJ THELEN'S COLLECTION
The Thelen Reserve
Behind the Bottles / California & Kentucky / Oak Bill finishing

Broken Barrel Whiskey Co.

Last updated Last researched

Broken Barrel Whiskey Co.

Break the barrel. Build a recipe.

A sledgehammer makes an arresting introduction to whiskey. The more interesting part comes afterward: deciding which pieces of wood belong together, what spirit should meet them, and when the combination is ready. Broken Barrel grew from Seth Benhaim’s infusion experiments into a whiskey producer built around that second recipe, the Oak Bill. Its story connects California experimentation, Kentucky contract production and a growing vocabulary of finishing woods. Following those roles reveals how a sourced whiskey can acquire a distinct creative identity.[2][6][17]

Symbolic broken oak cask, finishing staves, whiskey and barrel-breaking tools
Brand founded
2017[6]
Founder
Seth Benhaim[1][10]
Creative base
Los Angeles, California[6][12]
Signature method
Oak Bill stave finishing[6][4]
01 / Origins & people

An experiment becomes a whiskey identity.

An infusion idea finds another medium

Benhaim’s earlier business, Infuse Spirits, began in a family garage in 2012. Its bottles made the infusion process visible through real ingredients. Whiskey offered a related creative question: could the finishing wood become an ingredient chosen in deliberate combinations? In his later interviews, Benhaim traced the move into whiskey to 2017. The garage belongs to the parent venture’s origin story; the whiskey brand has its own starting date.[1][3]

A product name becomes a separate identity

The early whiskey carried Infuse Spirits branding. An October 2019 company announcement made Broken Barrel Whiskey Co. a distinct whiskey identity within Infuse Spirits Group. The announcement separated bottle-based vodka infusions from whiskey finished with staves in tanks. It also introduced the Single Oak Series under the new name, giving the separation a set of distinctive releases rather than a new label alone.[4]

The creator and the distiller have different jobs

The company’s January 2022 announcement identified its core bourbon and rye as sourced from Owensboro Distilling Co. in Kentucky. Later announcements used the Green River name for that production relationship. Benhaim described California experimentation alongside the larger Kentucky operation. Understanding Broken Barrel means following the selected whiskey, its maturation and its finishing recipe as related parts of a production chain.[6][2][17]

Symbolic whiskey blender hands comparing oak stave samples

Seth Benhaim

Founder / creative development

Founder and creative force behind the Oak Bill approach. In a 2024 interview, he described learning business through building Infuse Spirits and later Broken Barrel. A 2023 company announcement assigned him the title founder and chief creative officer, allowing more attention to creative development while another executive took responsibility for daily operations. Those dated accounts establish his role in the brand’s development.[1][10]

Simon Burch

CEO appointment announced April 2023

Infuse Spirits Group announced Burch as CEO in April 2023 and said he would become a major shareholder and join the executive board. His previous work included Green River and large international spirits portfolios. The announcement framed the relationship as a supplier-and-customer connection becoming a business partnership. It is a documented leadership transition; this research does not independently reconfirm executive titles in 2026.[10][11]

Jacob Call

Source-distillery credit in the 2022 announcement

The January 2022 core-line announcement named Call as the master distiller responsible for whiskey at Owensboro Distilling Co. His inclusion identifies the human work behind the sourced core liquid at that point in time. The credit belongs to the dated supply relationship and should not be read as a current Broken Barrel staff appointment.[6]

Laurel Canyon Spirits

Coffee-liqueur collaborator

The California collaborator supplied the coffee-liqueur barrel story behind Black Hjerte. The 2023 joint release traced the liqueur’s origins to Bryan and Dayna Turcotte’s family recipe and the business developed with Tammy and Nathan Ehrenfeld. Their contribution was a specific collaboration and its seasoned casks, rather than ownership of Broken Barrel.[12]

02 / The illustrated history

A second recipe changes the story.

Follow the infusion origins, separate whiskey identity, Kentucky production and expanding finishing vocabulary. Each date belongs to its documented event.

Symbolic illustration: The garage before the whiskey
2012

The garage before the whiskey

Benhaim begins the Infuse Spirits venture in his grandmother’s garage. His later account describes a small, hands-on start that precedes Broken Barrel by several years.[1][10]

Symbolic illustration: Whiskey enters the experiment
2017

Whiskey enters the experiment

The brand dates its founding to 2017. In a founder interview, Benhaim recalls the first whiskey release and the move from individual bottle infusions toward finishing whiskey with pieces of oak.[6][3]

Symbolic illustration: Rye and higher strength broaden the range
2018

Rye and higher strength broaden the range

Benhaim’s retrospective account places the addition of a rye and a cask-strength bourbon in 2018. These branches give the finishing approach different grain profiles and strengths to work with.[3]

Symbolic illustration: A whiskey identity of its own
2019

A whiskey identity of its own

The October rebranding announcement separates Broken Barrel from the Infuse Spirits name and introduces the Single Oak Series. Mizunara, Isle of Peat and Cask of Amontillado explore different woods and whiskey blends.[4]

Symbolic illustration: California research gains a licensed setting
Early 2021

California research gains a licensed setting

In his 2021 Whiskey Lore interview, Benhaim says a distilling license was obtained at the end of the first quarter. He describes small research and blending projects alongside the much larger Kentucky-sourced operation.[2]

Symbolic illustration: The range returns in new packaging
August 2021

The range returns in new packaging

A Bourbon Lens visit to Owensboro documents the refreshed bottles and a reintroduction of the brand. Its accompanying lineup distinguishes Small Batch, California Oak, Heresy Rye and Cask Strength.[5]

Symbolic illustration: The Kentucky core is set out in detail
January 2022

The Kentucky core is set out in detail

The company’s January 25 announcement describes the four-expression core, its Kentucky source and separate mash bills and Oak Bills. The recipes provide a clear snapshot of the range at that time.[6]

Symbolic illustration: Americana brings another blend
November 2022

Americana brings another blend

A November 9 announcement adds the 100-proof Americana to the core. Its finishing recipe combines charred American oak, toasted American oak and apple-brandy-cask staves. A founder interview explains the Indiana and Kentucky whiskey components.[7][8]

Symbolic illustration: Recognition in two different competitions
February 2023

Recognition in two different competitions

The organiser’s results name Broken Barrel the Icons of Whisky America Brand Innovator and its Cask Strength Bourbon Best Kentucky Finished Bourbon. The latter is a regional category award, distinct from the World’s Best Finished Bourbon title.[9]

Symbolic illustration: Business and creative leadership separate
April 2023

Business and creative leadership separate

Infuse Spirits Group announces Simon Burch as CEO and a shareholder, with Benhaim moving to founder and chief creative officer. The release describes a next phase for the parent company and its brands.[10][11]

Symbolic illustration: Coffee casks enter the collection
November 8, 2023

Coffee casks enter the collection

The Black Hjerte collaboration with Laurel Canyon Spirits combines Kentucky rye and light whiskey with coffee-liqueur-cask staves. The release identifies a second limited Collaboration Collection offering, bottled at 107 proof.[12]

Symbolic illustration: Honey Smoke takes a different base
November 28, 2023

Honey Smoke takes a different base

Honey Smoke Reserva follows the earlier Honey Smoke Rye with a six-year Kentucky American whiskey. The announcement specifies five months with honey and Texas sotol barrel staves, then bottling at 110 proof.[13]

Original watercolor interpretations accompany the history. Buildings, objects and scenes are symbolic, not documentary reconstructions.

03 / Geography & roles

One name. Several places that matter.

Symbolic Los Angeles workshop and Kentucky warehouse montage

Los Angeles: the creative workshop

The January 2022 release describes a Los Angeles warehouse collecting barrels, testing finishing combinations, blending and bottling limited projects. Benhaim’s interviews supply the working picture: a library of spirits and wood samples, repeated tasting and small experiments. This is the development side of the story, alongside the larger Kentucky production relationship.[6][2][8]

Owensboro: the core whiskey source

Company announcements identify Owensboro Distilling Co., later named Green River Distilling, as the supplier of the core Kentucky bourbon and rye. A 2022 founder interview describes contracted production, maturation, finishing and bottling there. Green River’s own history places renewed whiskey production at its historic site in 2016. That facility history belongs to the supplier; Broken Barrel’s brand dates to 2017.[6][17][15]

The Los Angeles Stave House

Dated 2022 and 2023 announcements list the Stave House and Bottle Shop at 2332 East 8th Street. It served as a place to encounter limited bottles and the creative operation. The address is preserved as a documented part of the history. Current opening hours and visitor access were not verified during this review, so it is not presented as a current visit recommendation.[6][12]

California’s Central Coast: a cask connection

California Oak’s January 2022 specification uses Cabernet Sauvignon cask staves with new French oak. The connection to California wine country is the finishing wood and its prior use, while the announced bourbon was Kentucky distilled. A cask’s journey can contribute a second geography without changing where the underlying whiskey was made.[6][5]

Indiana and the wider cask library

The 2019 Single Oak release and the later Americana interview establish Indiana whiskey as part of selected blends. Other woods carry links to Japanese Mizunara, Scottish peated-whisky casks, Spanish sherry and later coffee, honey and sotol barrels. These are release-specific sourcing and finishing relationships, rather than a claim that every Broken Barrel whiskey follows one route.[4][8][12][13]

04 / The whiskey family

Understand the name on the label.

Follow the parent venture, creative producer, source distillery and release-specific collaborators.

Broken Barrel Whiskey Co.

Producer / finisher / whiskey brand

The whiskey producer and finishing brand established in 2017, with a separate public whiskey identity announced in 2019. Its distinguishing work is choosing and combining whiskey and finishing staves.[6][4]

Infuse Spirits Group

Parent company in dated announcements

The 2019 rebranding release and April 2023 leadership announcement identify Infuse Spirits Group as the parent venture. The vodka and whiskey lines share an entrepreneurial origin while using different products, processes and branding. Current ownership percentages were not established.[4][10]

Green River / Owensboro Distilling

Core whiskey supply and production partner

The named source and production partner for the dated core Kentucky bourbon and rye range. Supplier identity and the Broken Barrel creative brand remain separate. That relationship does not establish the source of every later limited blend.[6][17]

Bardstown Bourbon Company

Owner in the source-distillery chain

Green River’s transaction adviser reported its sale to Bardstown Bourbon Company in July 2022. This places a change in the supplier’s corporate history. It does not establish that Bardstown acquired Broken Barrel or Infuse Spirits Group.[16][10]

Laurel Canyon Spirits / Black Hjerte

Release-specific collaborator

The November 2023 collaboration supplies a precise example of two California creative businesses meeting through seasoned wood. Coffee liqueur barrels become part of the whiskey’s finishing recipe; the release does not announce a corporate merger.[12]

Single Oak, Reserve Oak and Americana

Selected whiskey families

The family extends beyond the four-expression Kentucky core through experimental wood selections, blended whiskeys and limited releases. The 2019 announcement and 2022 founder interview describe different sources and recipes. Read each edition on its own terms.[4][8]

Seth Benhaim’s wider creative work

Founder’s wider business context

A September 2024 interview discusses Badwater Brands as another business developed from Benhaim’s experience building spirits brands. It provides context for his creative career without making every venture discussed there a subsidiary of Broken Barrel.[1]

05 / Making & choosing

The choices behind the label.

Distillation, blending, barrel selection and brand ownership play different roles. Keep every production claim tied to its facility, expression and date.

Symbolic steel finishing tank, oak staves and separately matured whiskey

The first recipe is grain

The January 2022 announcement gives the bourbon base as 70% corn, 21% rye and 9% barley, and Heresy Rye as 95% rye and 5% barley. Those are dated specifications. Benhaim’s earlier interview describes recipe changes over time, reinforcing why a historical bottle should be matched to its own label and edition.[6][2]

The second recipe is wood

An Oak Bill records the finishing-stave selection. The 2022 Small Batch, Heresy and Cask Strength descriptions use 40% ex-bourbon, 40% new French oak and 20% sherry-cask staves. California Oak uses 80% Cabernet-cask and 20% new French-oak staves. These percentages describe wood recipes, not the grain composition or percentages of finished whiskey from different distilleries.[6]

Maturation comes before finishing

The company’s 2022 account starts with whiskey aged for at least two years, followed by selection, dumping and batching into tanks. Chosen staves then contact the whiskey during finishing. The process builds on an already matured base. It does not make a finishing period interchangeable with the whiskey’s underlying age.[6]

Several woods can meet the same whiskey

Benhaim describes the original recipe as a blending exercise with separately tested woods before finding a preferred balance. In production, the selected staves can finish the batch together. The shape and exposed surfaces of detached staves change the contact with spirit, but the sources do not support a universal claim that this duplicates decades of barrel maturation.[2]

Wood has a species and a previous life

New French oak, ex-bourbon wood and a coffee-liqueur cask offer different starting conditions. In a 2022 interview Benhaim discussed the practical shift toward domestic sherry casks for the core, including freshness and supply consistency. A label saying sherry-cask staves should therefore not automatically be expanded into a specific Spanish origin or sherry style for every edition.[17][12]

Proof and finishing time belong to the release

The January 2022 announcement listed Small Batch at 95 proof and Cask Strength at 115. Honey Smoke Reserva’s 2023 announcement specified 110 proof and five months of finishing. Those figures explain particular releases; they are not universal settings for the whole brand. A higher number alone does not establish that two historical bottles are the same edition.[6][13]

06 / The details worth knowing

The stories inside the barrels.

The broken barrel is a working object

The hammer imagery began with physically opening casks to obtain staves. Benhaim’s interviews make the performance memorable, but they also describe the quieter work behind it: selecting wood, testing samples and adjusting a recipe. The image of destruction is the introduction to a process of assembly.[2][17]

A family tool becomes an emblem

In a 2022 interview, Benhaim said he used his grandfather’s pickaxe when breaking barrels in Los Angeles and connected the tool on the bottle to him. It is an attributed family recollection that explains the visual language of the brand, rather than evidence of a multigenerational commercial distillery.[17]

Heresy gives an objection a name

In a founder interview, Benhaim recalls someone calling the idea of putting barrel pieces into whiskey heresy. He adopted the word for the rye. The anecdote fits the brand’s provocative identity, while the production records supply the concrete explanation of what the whiskey actually undergoes.[3]

A new look still needs a bottle supply

The 2021 packaging refresh appears straightforward in photographs. In a later interview, Benhaim described a lengthy gap in receiving the new glass and the effect that had on the rollout. It is a reminder that a whiskey’s commercial history includes cartons, glass and logistics alongside barrels and recipes.[5][8]

Keep the award inside its category

The 2023 organiser’s record distinguishes Broken Barrel’s Brand Innovator win from its Cask Strength Bourbon’s Best Kentucky Finished Bourbon award. The same results give World’s Best Finished Bourbon to Ironroot Republic’s Apotheosis. Keeping that distinction preserves the achievement without turning a regional category result into a different title.[9]

A cask can connect two drinks

Black Hjerte connects whiskey to coffee liqueur through seasoned barrel staves. Honey Smoke Reserva follows another path, pairing honey and sotol barrel histories with an American whiskey base. Both releases show why the previous contents of wood matter, and why an evocative finish name should be read alongside the precise edition announcement.[12][13]

07 / Selected expressions

Different ways into the whiskey family.

A curated reading of the whiskey family, selected for its role in the story. This is not an exhaustive current catalog.

Small Batch Bourbon

The January 2022 snapshot presents a 95-proof Kentucky bourbon finished with the three-part ex-bourbon, new French oak and sherry Oak Bill. It is the clearest introduction to the core wood recipe. Historical versions and later bottlings require their own label confirmation.[6]

California Oak

The 88-proof bourbon in the same announcement places Cabernet-cask staves at the center of its finishing recipe. Its significance is the link between a Kentucky bourbon base and a California wine-cask influence. The name describes that relationship without making it California-distilled bourbon.[6]

Heresy Rye and Cask Strength

The rye introduces a different grain profile, while Cask Strength offers a higher-strength bourbon branch. In the January 2022 snapshot they share the three-part Oak Bill with Small Batch, at 105 and 115 proof respectively. The common wood recipe makes the differences in base whiskey and strength particularly instructive.[6]

The 2019 Single Oak Series

Mizunara, Isle of Peat and Cask of Amontillado expanded the brand beyond a single Kentucky bourbon recipe. The announcement describes Kentucky and Indiana components and different blends, including wheat and malt whiskey. These were specific limited releases, rather than an assertion that the same bottles remain available today.[4]

Americana

The November 2022 release adds a 100-proof American whiskey with a charred-oak, toasted-oak and apple-brandy-stave finish. Benhaim’s accompanying interview describes Indiana corn or light whiskey blended with Green River bourbon. Americana makes the limits of a blanket Kentucky-only source assumption clear.[7][8]

Black Hjerte Collaboration

The November 2023 release combines Kentucky rye and light whiskey and finishes the blend with two coffee-liqueur-cask stave selections. At 107 proof, the collaboration connects coffee, blood-orange liqueur and whiskey through the wood’s previous contents. The issuer prints the stave proportions as 66% and 33%; these rounded figures are retained as source information rather than silently corrected.[12]

Honey Smoke Reserva

The November 2023 announcement specifies six-year Kentucky American whiskey, a 99% corn and 1% malted-barley recipe, and five months with equal parts honey and Texas sotol barrel staves. Bottled at 110 proof, it is a different base and edition from the earlier Honey Smoke Rye.[13]

08 / The Reserve connection

Continue from the story to the bottles.

Broken Barrel Whiskey Co. in The Thelen Reserve

One Small Batch record connects this story to the collection: 116 proof, batch 5. Its exact historical label and recipe remain unverified; later core specifications are not substituted.

Approved watercolor of Broken Barrel Cask Strength Bourbon Whiskey

Broken Barrel Cask Strength Bourbon Whiskey

W0115 · 116 proof · Batch 5

Inventory records 116 proof and batch 5. Exact historical label and recipe remain unverified; do not substitute the later 95-proof Small Batch or 115-proof Cask Strength specifications.

Collection snapshot: October 25, 2026. One physical record. Approved artwork appears only where an exact record or verified release match is available.

Broken Barrel three-page guide cover
The illustrated companion

Broken Barrel Whiskey Co., in three pages.

Origins and people, history and places, whiskey and stories. A concise companion to this complete profile, with linked research sources.

Sources & research notes

Researched October 19, 2026. Official brand and company pages, dated announcements and clearly identified supporting sources are distinguished in the research. Product specifications are release- and market-specific.

Research qualifications

  • Research checked October 19, 2026. The official Broken Barrel site could not be retrieved. Dated company and agency announcements, first-person founder interviews, the supplier’s site, a transaction adviser and competition organisers support this profile. Current availability, visitor access and unchanged executive titles are not presumed.[6][10][1][9]
  • The 2012 garage story concerns Infuse Spirits; company releases date Broken Barrel to 2017 and the separate whiskey rebranding to 2019. Supplier history is kept separate from brand founding.[1][6][4]
  • The leadership announcement is posted April 17, 2023 but contains an April 17, 2022 dateline. April 2023 independent reporting corroborates the appointment. The timeline therefore uses April 2023 and records the conflicting dateline here.[10][11]
  • The organiser records Best Kentucky Finished Bourbon for Broken Barrel Cask Strength in 2023. World’s Best Finished Bourbon belongs to Ironroot Republic’s Apotheosis in that same list. Brand Innovator is a separate Icons of Whisky award.[9]
  • The core recipes and proofs are tied to the January 2022 announcement. Founder interviews describe changes in recipe and wood sourcing. They do not authenticate an unphotographed historical batch.[6][2][17]
  • Americana and limited editions can include sources beyond the Kentucky core. Supplier ownership does not establish ownership of the Broken Barrel brand. Black Hjerte’s published 66%/33% stave figures are rounded source values; no exact missing percentage is inferred.[8][16][12]
  • Promotional statements assigning a fixed percentage of flavor to oak, claiming unique world-first status or implying that finishing replaces long maturation are not treated as independently established measurements. Product descriptions here explain documented methods and releases.[6][2]
  • The TAG organiser’s 2024 table lists scores of 90 for Americana, 93 for Black Hjerte, 91 for Cask Strength, 93 for Heresy and 89 for Small Batch. Those results are dated competition records, not a rating of every subsequent bottle.[14]

Full sources

  1. Park Street — founder interview, September 17, 2024First-person business origins, 2012 garage and wider creative career. Note: Founder recollection; does not verify current brand ownership or availability.
  2. Whiskey Lore — Seth Benhaim interview, 2021Founder account of sourcing, recipe development, 2017 start and early-2021 license. Note: Retrospective interview; transcription errors and forward plans are not verified events.
  3. The Bourbon Road — episode 190, founder interview2017 whiskey entry, 2018 expansion, 2019 rebranding and Heresy anecdote. Note: Founder recollection from the 2021 period; avoid general legal conclusions in transcript.
  4. Infuse Spirits — October 3, 2019 rebranding releaseDistinct whiskey identity, tank/stave method and three Single Oak editions. Note: Company press release; availability and recipes are specific to the announcement.
  5. Bourbon Lens — Owensboro visit, August 22, 2021Contemporaneous packaging refresh and four-expression lineup. Note: Visit/interview plus producer descriptions; 2021 specifications only.
  6. RoBro — Broken Barrel core announcement, January 25, 2022Founding, Kentucky source, four core proofs, mash/Oak Bills and LA warehouse. Note: Brand agency release. Historical portfolio snapshot; fixed flavor percentages are promotional.
  7. Broken Barrel — Americana announcement, November 9, 2022Americana launch, 100 proof and charred/toasted/apple-brandy Oak Bill. Note: Company press release. Boilerplate about Kentucky core must not erase blend-specific sources.
  8. The Bourbon Road — episode 326, December 2022 interviewAmericana Indiana/Kentucky blend, LA projects, packaging supply and limited editions. Note: First-person account; plans for following year are not treated as completed launches.
  9. Whisky Magazine — organiser’s 2023 America resultsFebruary 2023 Brand Innovator and Best Kentucky Finished Bourbon results. Note: Regional/product categories distinguished from global winners and from one another.
  10. RoBro — Simon Burch appointment, posted April 17, 2023Parent company, Burch appointment/shareholding and Benhaim creative role. Note: Body dateline says 2022; publication and corroborating reporting are April 2023. No 2026 title assurance.
  11. The Spirits Business — appointment report, April 21, 2023Independent date corroboration for the leadership transition. Note: Secondary corroboration of the announcement; historical appointment only.
  12. Broken Barrel — Black Hjerte announcement, November 8, 2023Laurel Canyon collaboration, rye/light blend, coffee woods, proof and family origins. Note: Company release. Printed stave percentages 66/33 are rounded; no reclassification of the blend.
  13. Broken Barrel — Honey Smoke Reserva, November 28, 2023Six-year Kentucky base, 110 proof, five months and honey/sotol staves. Note: Specific 2023 edition. World-first promotional claim is not independently adopted.
  14. TAG Global Spirits Awards — 2024 resultsOrganiser’s expression-specific 2024 scores. Note: Scores apply to entries in that competition, not the entire brand or future batches.
  15. Green River — official Owensboro distillery accountSupplier’s Owensboro location and 2016 return to production. Note: Supplier’s own history; does not verify a current Broken Barrel contract.
  16. Cascadia Capital — Green River sale, July 21, 2022Transaction adviser confirms Green River sale to Bardstown Bourbon Company. Note: Supplier transaction, not evidence that Broken Barrel was acquired.
  17. American Whiskey Magazine — founder interview, August 8, 2022Working method, new French oak, domestic sherry, family pickaxe and site roles. Note: First-person interview; historical visitor hours and current operations not presumed.
↑